Japanese baseball participant Shohei Ohtani attends a press convention on his presentation after signing a 10-year take care of the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodgers Stadium in Los Angeles, California, on Dec. 14, 2023.
Frederic J. Brown | AFP | Getty Images
Roughly a month after Shohei Ohtani signed a $700 million contract with Major League Baseball’s Los Angeles Dodgers, California’s controller is looking for “fast and decisive motion” from Congress to restrict deferred income for larger earners.
The Japanese pitcher’s record-breaking deal defers $680 million for 10 years and has raised questions about future state taxability — particularly if Ohtani ultimately leaves California. For 2024, California’s high tax fee is 14.4%, which features a 1.1% payroll levy.
“The present tax system permits for limitless deferrals for these lucky sufficient to be within the highest tax brackets, creating a major imbalance within the tax construction,” California State Controller Malia Cohen stated in a statement Monday referencing Ohtani’s contract.
More from Personal Finance:
Tax filing season kicks off Jan. 29. Here’s what taxpayers need to know
It’s time to boost 401(k) contributions for 2024. Here’s how much to save
Issues with the new FAFSA rollout leaves students, families frustrated
“The absence of cheap caps on deferral for the wealthiest people exacerbates income inequality and hinders the truthful distribution of taxes,” she stated. “I might urge Congress to take fast and decisive motion to rectify this imbalance.”
Deferring $68 million yearly for 10 years might save Ohtani $98 million over the lifetime of his contract, in accordance with an estimate from the California Center for Jobs and the Economy. However, the estimate makes use of a number of assumptions, and the precise phrases of Ohtani’s contract are unknown.
While California’s controller calls for restrictions on deferred income, that might not be the supply of the issue, in accordance with Steve Rosenthal, senior fellow on the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.
“What’s actually going on here’s a federal law that was enacted in 1995 by a Republican Congress to forestall states from taxing pension income,” he stated. “The drawback with Ohtani is he can return to Japan and sidestep California taxes.”
The provision prevents states from taxing nonresident “retirement income,” which might embody deferred compensation.
Deferred income hasn’t been a precedence for Congress
While some Democrats have referred to as for higher taxes on the wealthy, lawmakers have centered on areas corresponding to so-called unrealized positive factors, or funding progress, somewhat than deferred income, stated William McBride, vp of federal tax coverage on the Tax Foundation.
“Deferred income runs all through the tax code,” corresponding to income from your 401(k) or govt compensation, he stated.
If Congress enacted restrictions on deferred income, it will “put the state in a worse place when it comes to its capacity to gather income from these high earners and star athletes as a result of they would not be there,” McBride stated.
Don’t miss these tales from CNBC PRO: