Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks throughout a press convention at the Commonwealth of Independent States’ head of states assembly on Oct. 13, 2023, in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan.
Getty Images
With Russia’s invasion of Ukraine its most urgent geopolitical precedence for at the very least the final 19 months, Moscow has not had a lot time or alternative to carry as a lot power and affect over all its other neighbors — a place it has loved since the breakup of the Soviet Union greater than 30 years in the past.
Russia’s affect in components of the South Caucasus area — which incorporates Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia — and other former Soviet republics akin to Belarus and people additional afield, akin to Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, differs from state to state. It’s additionally largely depending on the diploma of pro-Western or pro-Russian sentiment amongst the individuals and management, in addition to the stage of financial and geopolitical reliance on Moscow.
But analysts say one factor is for sure: The warfare in Ukraine has created the irony {that a} distracted Russia has misplaced a level of power, management and leverage over its personal wider yard.
Azerbaijan troopers regulate visitors as refugees wait of their automobiles to go away Karabakh for Armenia, at the in Lachin border, on Sept. 26, 2023.
Emmanuel Dunand | Afp | Getty Images
Azerbaijan’s seizing of breakaway area Nagorno-Karabakh from Armenia in September highlighted Russia’s considerably weakened or reshaped function in the area — given its perceived lack of anticipation of the offensive and lack of intervention in a long-running dispute during which it has historically been a mediator.
In an indication that Russia was caught off guard by the battle in its personal yard, simply sooner or later earlier than Azerbaijan launched its lightning offensive, Russia’s Foreign Ministry said in a statement that the humanitarian scenario was enhancing in Nagorno-Karabakh and hoped that may assist the “normalising” of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations.
This pool {photograph} distributed by Russian state owned company Sputnik reveals Russia’s President Vladimir Putin and his Kyrgyz counterpart Sadyr Japarov attending a welcoming ceremony previous to their talks in Bishkek on October 12, 2023.
Sergei Karpukhin | AFP | Getty Images
The Kremlin rejects accusations that it now not has the management standing it as soon as loved, with President Vladimir Putin’s Press Secretary Dmitry Peskov telling CNBC that “there isn’t any such risk” that Moscow’s affect has waned amongst its neighbors.
“Each space is equally essential for Russia. Russia continues to play its function in the Caucasus,” Peskov mentioned in emailed feedback.
Russia seen in a brand new mild
Geopolitical analysts usually are not so unequivocal, saying Russia’s failure to grab Ukraine in a matter of days — as Moscow anticipated — when its forces first invaded in February 2022, confirmed its army capabilities in a brand new mild to its neighbors.
“The query arose about the actual combating capability of the Russian military,” Vira Konstantinova, political scientist and worldwide relations specialist, advised CNBC.
Within the first month of combating, and with Russian forces withdrawing from the outskirts of Kyiv, Ukraine’s armed forces had managed to debunk a “key fable of Russian propaganda,” she famous — that Russia’s military was highly effective, effectively geared up and succesful.
In truth, she mentioned, Kyiv’s resistance highlighted to Russia’s neighbors and companions that “Russian power is a bubble with solely a nuclear button in its heart.”
Russian President Vladimir Putin enters the corridor throughout Russian-Uzbek talks at the Grand Kremlin Palace on Oct. 6, 2023.
Getty Images
Russian opposition politician Vladimir Milov, who as soon as labored below Putin in the early days of his management, earlier than turning into disillusioned with Russia’s geopolitical course of journey, agreed that the warfare in Ukraine has, satirically, made Russia look weaker amongst its post-Soviet neighbors.
“If you are taking Ukraine out of the equation it is actually clear that Russia doesn’t management the post-Soviet area, as Ukraine is larger and extra essential than every part else. So it is truthful to say that if you don’t management Ukraine, you don’t management the post-Soviet area,” he advised CNBC.
“When it was clear that Russia was failing to ascertain dominance over Ukraine, all people else additionally noticed that and began to behave extra independently. People see that they [Russia] shouldn’t be reaching this ultimate job and which means they’re weak and have to show elsewhere,” he famous.
Milov mentioned there was once two colleges of thought in Russia 20 years in the past: one is that Moscow wanted to reassert dominance over its post-Soviet neighbors and one other — adopted by Milov — believed Russia’s neighbors needs to be handled as equals and built-in, with Russia, right into a broader Western area.
Milov mentioned his faculty of thought had been erased over time — Putin, he mentioned, “squeezed it out.”
Opportunity for the West
Geopolitical analysts say Russia’s affect may have been shaken, however has actually not disappeared — it stays a superpower amongst its neighbors and the risk of additional Russian intervention in Russian-backed breakaway areas akin to Transnistria in Moldova and Abkhazia and South Ossetia in Georgia has not been discounted.
Igor Semivolos, government director of the Center for Middle East Studies in Ukraine, famous that whereas it could possibly be mentioned that the “depth” of Russia’s interactions in what it sees as its yard has declined — significantly because it “concentrates the foremost effort on the Ukrainian query” — it isn’t fully appropriate to say that “Russia has misplaced its grip.”
“In normal, up to now, the weakening is noticed solely in the context of the discount of Russia’s international coverage initiatives on this area,” he advised CNBC in emailed feedback, including that Russia nonetheless “maneuvers and tries to distribute the assets to maintain the scenario below management.”
But if Western nations needed to take the alternative to interrupt Russia’s more and more precarious maintain over its neighbors, international coverage initiatives and safety ensures are wanted now, he mentioned.
“It’s essential that other powers begin getting into the area. The USA and Turkey [could] provide the international locations their very own safety formulation [guarantees], and maybe in the future, these safety formulation will change into extra enticing than the Russian one,” he mentioned.
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev addresses the nation after “anti-terror actions” organized by the Azerbaijani military in Karabakh, which resulted in a cease-fire in Baku, Azerbaijan, on Sept. 20, 2023.
Anadolu Agency | Anadolu Agency | Getty Images
Analysts say the West ought to actually be reaching out to such Eurasian international locations whereas the alternative presents itself, and Russia is distracted with Ukraine. Azerbaijan’s resolution to strike Armenia whereas Russia’s again was turned, metaphorically, confirmed that Moscow’s palms are largely tied, they word.
“Russia’s warfare on Ukraine has shaken stability in the South Caucasus, and Moscow may attempt to claw again affect in the area at the expense of regional peace and safety,” Vasif Huseynov, head of the Western Studies division at the Center of Analysis of International Relations, a suppose tank primarily based in Azerbaijan, famous in evaluation.
But better U.S. engagement with the likes of Azerbaijan might “reinforce a platform for peace between Azerbaijan and Armenia” and will assist “counter threats to shared pursuits” from Moscow and Tehran, he famous.