COP28 president sparks outcry after claims there’s ‘no science’ behind fossil fuel phase out
COP28 president sparks outcry after claims there’s ‘no science’ behind fossil fuel phase out


Sultan Al-Jaber, chief govt officer of Abu Dhabi National Oil Co. and president of COP28, speaks in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, on Saturday, Dec. 2, 2023.

Bloomberg | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Dubai, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES — COP28 President Sultan Al-Jaber is dealing with a backlash over his declare that there’s “no science” behind requires a phase out of fossil fuels — a requirement that many believe will in the end decide the success of the U.N. local weather convention.

In feedback first reported on Sunday by The Guardian and investigative journalism group the Centre for Climate Reporting, COP28 president and United Arab Emirates local weather chief Al-Jaber prompt a fossil fuel phase out wouldn’t enable sustainable growth “except you need to take the world again into caves.”

The remarks, which had been made by Al-Jaber throughout a reside on-line occasion on Nov. 21, have been described by scientists and advocates as “farcical,” “beyond astonishing” and verging on climate denial.

In a social media publish, University of Pennsylvania local weather scientist Michael Mann accused Al-Jaber of “making an entire mockery” of the COP28 talks and urged U.N. chief Antonio Guterres to talk out on the problem.

Al-Jaber was seen as a controversial choice to guide COP28 discussions in Dubai on condition that he additionally works as the top of the state-run Abu Dhabi National Oil Company.

A spokesperson for COP28 informed CNBC that the story relating to Al-Jaber’s feedback was “simply one other try and undermine the Presidency’s agenda, which has been clear and clear and backed by tangible achievements by the COP President and his workforce.”

They stated Al-Jaber has been “unwavering” in saying that maintaining international warming to 1.5°C entails motion throughout various areas and sectors. “The COP President is evident that phasing down and out of fossil fuels is inevitable and that we should maintain 1.5°C inside attain. We usually are not positive what this story was supposedly revealing. Nothing in it’s new or breaking information.”

If we fail with the phase out on fossil fuels then we’re not going to achieve success on local weather mitigation.

Petteri Taalas

WMO Secretary General

The 1.5 levels Celsius temperature threshold is well known as essential as a result of so-called tipping factors turn into extra possible past this stage. Tipping factors are thresholds at which small adjustments can result in dramatic shifts in Earth’s total life help system.

Looking forward, “the COP President is concentrated on working with events to ship a plan that can ship most transition and minimal disruption for everybody on the earth,” the spokesperson stated. “He has repeatedly communicated our place on fossil fuels and invited all events to work collectively and provide you with options that may obtain alignment, widespread floor and consensus.”

The spokesperson added that the COP28 host has been “excited with the progress” made up to now and for the supply of a choice on the worldwide inventory take. “Attempts to undermine this won’t soften our resolve,” they stated.

‘Very primary physics’

The outcry over Al-Jaber’s feedback comes as COP28 gears up for a fight over the future of fossil rules.

For almost three many years, policymakers representing almost 200 nations on the U.N.’s annual local weather convention have tried to deal with the chief driver of the climate crisis: the burning of coal, oil and fuel.

The language of the ultimate settlement, anticipated by or across the Dec. 12 finish of the convention, can be carefully monitored. A “phase out” dedication would possible require a shift away from fossil fuels till their use is eradicated, whereas a “phase down” may point out a discount of their use — however not an absolute finish.

There’s additionally an ongoing debate about whether or not an settlement ought to heart on “abated” fossil fuels, that are trapped and stocked with carbon seize and storage applied sciences, or “unabated” fossil fuels, that are largely understood to be produced and used with out substantial reductions within the quantity of emitted greenhouse gases.

DUBAI, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES – DECEMBER 3: In this handout picture suppled by COP28, Petteri Taalas, Secretary-general of the World Meteorological Organization, attends the occasion ‘Delivering Early Warnings For All’, throughout day 4 of the UNFCCC COP28 Climate Conference at Expo City Dubai on December 3, 2023 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. The COP28, which is operating from November 30 by way of December 12, is bringing collectively stakeholders, together with worldwide heads of state and different leaders, scientists, environmentalists, indigenous peoples representatives, activists and others to debate and agree on the implementation of world measures in direction of mitigating the results of local weather change. (Photo by Kiara Worth /COP28 through Getty Images)

Handout | Getty Images News | Getty Images

“If we fail with the phase out on fossil fuels then we’re not going to achieve success on local weather mitigation,” Petteri Taalas, secretary common of the U.N.’s World Meteorological Organization, informed CNBC in Dubai.

Asked for a response to Al-Jaber’s feedback, Taalas stated there’s “very clear science” behind requires a fossil fuel phase out.

“This influence of carbon dioxide on atmospheric warming, that is very primary physics … There’s no query about that.”

U.S. local weather envoy John Kerry was additionally requested to replicate on Al-Jaber’s feedback. In an interview with CNBC’s Tania Bryer on Sunday, Kerry replied, “That’s not the argument.”

“The G7 nations voted that there must be a phasing out of unmitigated fossil fuel emissions and what there’s science for is maintaining 1.5 levels as your North Star,” Kerry stated.

“Every determination we make must be geared to say, ‘does this advance the 1.5 levels or is it going to be extra harmful and take us within the flawed course?'”

Separately, former U.S. vice president Al Gore reportedly stated Sunday that the UAE’s place as COP28 host was an abuse of public belief.

“They are abusing the general public’s belief by naming the CEO of one of many largest and least accountable oil firms on the earth as head of the COP,” Gore stated, in accordance with Reuters.

At the time of Al-Jaber’s appointment as COP28 president earlier this yr, his workplace said he would play a “essential function” in constructing consensus “and driving bold local weather outcomes.”

A spokesperson for ADNOC, which just lately grew to become the primary amongst its friends to deliver ahead its net-zero ambition to 2045, has beforehand said: “All of the present power transition situations, together with by the IEA, present that some stage of oil and fuel can be wanted into the long run.”



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *